Skip to main content

Padres have a reason to want Dustin May, and a reason to hesitate

Can they revive another former Dodgers starter?
ByBrandon Glick
Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May.
Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

One of the biggest success stories from the 2026 San Diego Padres was the revival of Walker Buehler. No, he didn't return to prime form when he finished fourth in NL Cy Young voting in 2021 with the Los Angeles Dodgers, but he made 32 starts and pitched to a 4.51 FIP in his debut campaign with the Friars. Considering how much he struggled in recent years, that performance was a huge win for both player and team.

So, with Buehler testing the free-agent market after his relatively successful season, why not try the same magic trick with another once-highly regarded Dodgers pitcher? Dustin May just won the World Series with the Milwaukee Brewers and is starting to gain a lot of traction on the open market. Would it make sense for the Padres to bring him as a member of the rotation?

Dustin May is finally healthy and can eat a lot of innings for Padres

May has made one really important stride in the past two years: he's finally gotten healthy. After failing to complete even 60 innings in any of his first six seasons in the big leagues, he handled sizable workloads of 132⅓ frames last year and 145⅔ this year. Including the postseason, the right-hander made 33 starts in 2026, surpassing the 150-inning threshold for the first time in his career.

You can certainly make the argument that his injury history is far too long to believe in this sudden reversal of fortunes, but May only recently turned 29 years old. He's still relatively young and, due to all of that time missed, has limited mileage on his arm. The Padres, who need to replace hundreds of innings handled by Buehler, Michael King, Adrian Morejon, and other this offseason, need volume as much as anything else.

May isn't just an empty-calories pitcher either; he was excellent in the first half with the Cardinals this year (3.15 FIP) and still has one of the biggest fastballs of any starter in the league. Ruben Niebla could have a field day with the right-hander's profile.

Paders must be wary of Dustin May's fading talent

Of course, May's results aren't limited to just that small sample in St. Louis. He's largely been a mess since coming back from Tommy John surgery in 2025 (4.82 ERA), recording -0.3 bWAR in that time. He was also practically unusable during the home stretch of the Brewers' postseason run, allowing seven runs in 11 innings.

He's just not particularly good at any one thing on the mound, and his hard-hit rate (44.3%) sat in the seventh percentile this past season. Whatever upside he once had as a top prospect in the Dodgers' system has been mostly washed away by a flood of injuries.

On a cheap one-year deal, May would be a fine option to give the Padres some badly needed length from their starting pitching corps. But making a long-term or hefty investment in him would reek of desparation.

Add us as a preferred source on Google