Just yesterday, I wrote about why the San Diego Padres would theoretically have interest in right-handed starter Dustin May. He's got an intriguing-enough profile, and he's finally healthy after years of making trip after trip to the injured list. When you're as desperate for pitching as the Friars are, that kind of player can be attractive.
What I did not account for, however, was that May would force a team to light a lot of money on fire. The Chicago White Sox wound up winning his sweepstakes, signing the former top prospect to a three-year, $52.5 million deal that blew even the most optimistic projections out of the water.
There's a few justifications for that contract that we'll discuss in a moment, but the bigger concern is what it means for teams like the Padres, who need to add a lot of starting pitching help and don't have a limitless budget to do so.
A.J. Preller's four-starter promise looks a lot more dubious in the wake of Dustin May's $52.5 million contract
As for those justifications, the broader scope take is that the White Sox might be preparing for a salary floor in a post-lockout world and are trying to be proactive in reaching whatever that figure will be. Their estimated 2027 payroll of $118 million (after signing May) is well short of the most recent salary floor proposal from the league (about $180 million).
The other main school of thought here is less promising for the Padres. May, who had a very strong performance with the Cardinals prior to the 2026 trade deadline (3.15 FIP), firmly put himself in back-end-of-the-rotation discussions this past season. A $17.5 million AAV sounds hefty, but it appears to be the going rate for that tier of pitcher these days.
If that latter sentiment is true, it could spell disaster for the Friars this offseason. A.J. Preller recently suggested that the team could bring in as many as four new starters; based on May's contract, accomplishing that goal exclusively through free agency will become an expensive endeavor in a hurry.
The problem is the Padres' farm system is also a mess, meaning they won't be able to trade for an established starter or one with team control. Unless Preller plans to fill out his rotation entirely with minor-league and bargain-bin signings, it's getting hard to envision how exactly he'll fulfill his promise.
The silver lining here is that the free-agent market is relatively deep for starting pitchers, though that clearly didn't hurt May's earning potential. The Padres will have options, but how many they can afford remains to be seen.
Maybe turning down Nick Pivetta's $14 million option wasn't such a great idea after all.
