The Padres worked some magic and found a way to keep Gavin Sheets before the non-tender deadline. The two sides agreed to a three-year, $11 million extension that includes a $500,000 signing bonus and two opt-outs, according to FanSided’s Robert Murray.
A day ago, we floated the idea of a multiyear deal. Sheets was projected to earn $6.5 million in his final year of arbitration, a number that was hard to justify after he slashed .212/.313/.397 with a .709 OPS in 2026. But cutting him loose would have sent A.J. Preller shopping for a left-handed hitter who could replace 17 home runs and cover first base, left field and DH. How much were the Padres really going to save once they paid to cover for that?
Taking Sheets to arbitration would have kept him around for another season. Non-tendering him would have given every other club a chance to sign him. The extension gave Preller a third way through the deadline, and it’s a worthwhile bet. The Padres already know how Craig Stammen can use Sheets, and there’s enough power here to justify keeping him in the lineup mix while Preller works on a rotation that needs help.
The opt-outs give Gavin Sheets a say in how long he stays with the Padres
The $11 million works out to about $3.67 million a year on average. The actual 2027 salary will tell us how much room the deal gives Preller this winter. We’re sure any savings here will likely go towards starting pitching.
For Sheets, the opt-outs are where this gets interesting. He came to San Diego on a minor-league deal in 2025 after the White Sox non-tendered him, then hit 19 homers in his first season with the Padres. Two years after Chicago let him go, he has a multiyear deal and two opportunities to test the market again. If his bat takes off, he has a way to cash in. We can also look at Sheets as a failsafe. Ty France is currently projected at receiving somewhere around $12-$16 million AAV. It’s hard to see the Padres offering that out while they’ve yet to sign a starting pitcher.
We’d still like to see Preller add another bat Stammen can write into the lineup most nights. Keeping Sheets makes that job a little easier. Stammen can move him around as the roster takes shape.
