Skip to main content

Why non-tendering Gavin Sheets could cost the Padres more than it saves

Seventeen homers is nothing to sneeze at
ByTremayne Person
Sep 30, 2026; San Diego, California, USA;  San Diego Padres first baseman Gavin Sheets (30) reacts after hitting a two run home run in the fifth inning against the Chicago Cubs during game two of the Wildcard round for the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Petco Park.  Mandatory Credit: Denis Poroy-Imagn Images
Sep 30, 2026; San Diego, California, USA; San Diego Padres first baseman Gavin Sheets (30) reacts after hitting a two run home run in the fifth inning against the Chicago Cubs during game two of the Wildcard round for the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Petco Park. Mandatory Credit: Denis Poroy-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Padres could take Gavin Sheets’ projected $6.5 million salary off the books on November 20. By Saturday, A.J. Preller could be in search of another left-handed bat who can play first base, stand out in left field and hit the ball out of Petco.

The Padres have every reason to hesitate at the number Sheets is in line to receive. He slashed .212/.313/.397 with a .709 OPS in 2026. It would make sense for the Friars to want more production than that. But he also hit 17 homers in 363 at-bats, and Craig Stammen could find him starts at first, in left or at DH.

The Padres know what it feels like to be on the other side of this kind of move. The White Sox ditched Sheets with a non-tender move after 2024. San Diego picked him up on a minor league deal and got 19 home runs out of him the following season. Preller got a bargain because Chicago was willing to let him go. Now Sheets finds himself on the fringe again. This time Preller has to decide what he’s willing to pay to find the next good deal.

The Padres need to price Gavin Sheets’ replacement before they cut him

The rotation is the best argument for freeing up the money. The Friars had seven starters reach free agency, so there are plenty of places Preller could allocate those resources. There’s a real case for letting Sheets go if the Padres have a cheaper bat they trust or a bigger lineup upgrade within reach. And what if the best bat they can get for the money is still Gavin Sheets?

Preller could offer Sheets a two-year deal that pays him less in 2027 than his projected $6.5 million arbitration salary. Sheets gets another guaranteed year in San Diego, and the Padres free up some money for the rotation without having to replace his power. They could still make that offer after non-tendering him. By then, so could everybody else.

That matters even more with Miguel Andújar and Ty France also in free agency. Move on from Sheets, too, and Stammen has another batch of at-bats to fill.

Also, the $6.5 million is just a projection. There’s room for the Padres to try to settle at a lower number before Friday. That should be the first move before this gets overcomplicated.

If the Padres have a better bat lined up, then go get it. If their plan is to cut Sheets and see what shakes loose, it’ll be another risky move with no guarantee of how it turns out.

Add us as a preferred source on Google