Jake Bauers hit one more home run than Fernando Tatis Jr. this season. Tatis had 54 more hits. If we had a vote in the NL utility Silver Slugger, that might be the starting point. It's also why seeing the award go to the Brewers slugger might be a tough sell in San Diego.
Hey, let’s give Bauers some credit though. He got on base more often, slugged .484 to Tatis’ .470 and finished with the better OPS. He hit 26 homers in 144 games and put up one hack of a season. Anybody arguing their case for Bauers has a very clean stance. We’d still give the silver bat to the guy who finished one homer behind him and racked up 63 more total bases.
Fernando Tatis Jr. gave the Padres more over a full season
Tatis played 159 games and hit .289. He collected 181 hits, including 32 doubles, and finished with 294 total bases. Bauers had 127 hits and 231 total bases. Some of that gap comes from opportunity. Tatis had 149 more at-bats, and those extra trips to the plate are part of what we’re giving him credit for. The Padres got to write his name into the lineup over and over, and he kept giving them a reason to look forward to his spot coming up.
The final line is striking when you consider how long we waited for the first home run. Tatis spent the early part of the season stuck on zero, then hit .299 with a .549 slugging percentage from his first homer onward. All of those early at-bats count. We watched the slump and it was pretty miserable. But after all that waiting, he ended up one swing away from matching Bauers in home runs anyway. If you only remember how loud the conversation got during the drought, the season he actually put together might surprise you.
Jake Bauers earned his spot on the utility ballot by playing first base and the corner outfield. Fernando Tatis Jr. earned his by playing right field and second base. Once both guys are on the ballot, we can get right to the question that matters. Whose season would you rather have had at the plate?
Bauers had the better OPS. But we’d take the 159 games, the 294 total bases and the ability to move from right field to second without taking that bat out of the lineup. The Padres got all of that from Tatis in the same season we spent weeks asking when he’d finally hit one out. He deserved the Silver Slugger for everything that came with it.
