Desperately seeking positive signs in Fernando Tatis Jr.'s Padres power vacuum

The Padres are more than a month into the season, and Fernando Tatis Jr. is still searching for his first homer. That’s jarring on its own. It gets even louder when we remember this isn’t a supporting bat being asked to chip in around the edges. 

So there is no need to dress it up in soft language. The drought has been brutal. The encouraging part, if we are desperately seeking one, is that this doesn’t look like a player who has stopped hitting the ball hard. Tatis had recorded 12 barrels, a total that normally would have produced roughly a half-dozen home runs by now. He also remains in the 99th percentile in hard-hit rate, which is not exactly the statistical profile of a hitter whose bat has gone missing.  

This isn’t a simple “he looks cooked” conversation. If it were, the Padres would have a much scarier problem. Instead, they have something more annoying, more confusing and probably more fixable: Tatis is still creating thunderous contact, but the contact is not turning into damage.

Fernando Tatis Jr. is still hitting the ball hard, but not in the way the Padres need

The issue isn’t just bad luck, even if some of this has clearly been ridiculous. Twelve barrels and zero homers is the kind of stat that makes you want to check the dimensions of every ballpark he has played in. At some point, a few of those balls should have disappeared. Baseball owes him at least one refund.

But the deeper issue is where the contact is going. Tatis isn’t pulling the ball the way he normally does. He’s pulling the ball just 20.8 percent of the time, well below both the league average and his career mark. He has also been using the middle and opposite fields at unusually high rates.

The Padres do not need Tatis to become a different kind of hitter. They need him to scare pitchers again. That version still feels like it is in there. But the shape of the contact has changed, and that is where the Padres’ concern should live.

The Padres’ lineup can function without Tatis going full MVP mode every night, but it becomes a completely different animal when he is driving the baseball. His power stretches the lineup. It changes how pitchers attack Manny Machado, Xander Bogaerts, Jackson Merrill, and everyone around him. It gives the Padres the kind of instant offense that can cover for rotation stress, bullpen fatigue or one of those weird San Diego nights where the offense spends six innings making a mid-tier starter look like Greg Maddux.

Without that, everything gets tighter.

The good news is that the positive signs are real. Tatis has not lost the ability to impact the baseball. The less comfortable part is that the Padres cannot just shrug and wait forever. At some point, process has to turn into production. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow