Skip to main content

The Padres’ rotation rebuild has a Ty France problem hiding at first base

First base looks cheap right up until you have to replace the hits.
ByTremayne Person
Sep 26, 2026; San Diego, California, USA;  San Diego Padres first baseman Ty France (25) hits an RBI groundout during the third inning against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Petco Park.  Mandatory Credit: David Frerker-Imagn Images
Sep 26, 2026; San Diego, California, USA; San Diego Padres first baseman Ty France (25) hits an RBI groundout during the third inning against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Petco Park. Mandatory Credit: David Frerker-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Padres can sign plenty of starting pitching this offseason and still come out of it a worse team. For instance, they can let Ty France leave, hand first base to Gavin Sheets by default, and we’ll get to see if that production still translates.

We understand why A.J. Preller is spending so much of his offseason talking about pitching. Michael King, Nick Pivetta and Walker Buehler are free agents. So are their trade deadline acquisitions in Casey Mize and Robbie Ray. Ryan Weiss became the first addition to a rotation that still needs several arms. In his offseason rundown for MLB.com, AJ Cassavell had starting pitching occupying practically the entire top of the Padres’ to-do list. The vacancy at first base came up near the end. It deserves a little more room than that.

France slashed .295/.363/.502 with 21 home runs in 133 games. We can get so caught up in how cheaply the Padres found those numbers that we forget what it would cost to replace them. The guy who came to camp on a minor league deal finished with an .865 OPS. Jackson Merrill had a .743 OPS. Manny Machado hit 30 home runs and finished at .710. When the big names had uneven years at the plate, France was one of the reasons the lineup could keep moving.

Why Gavin Sheets is a better fit for a part time role with the Padres

Sheets hit 17 home runs in 363 at-bats. We know the Padres still would like him to be available to provide left-handed pop. We also saw him slash .212/.313/.397. Compared with France, that’s 50 points of OBP and 105 points of slugging.

There’s a version of this roster where Sheets plays first against a tough righty, gets some time at DH and gives Stammen a pinch-hitting option off the bench. However, if he gets the everyday job, suddenly the same player you’d like to have available in specific spots is taking on a bigger share of the offense than his 2026 numbers justify.

Left field is also a need. If we’re picking one place to protect money for a bat, though, first base should still be the priority. 

Cassavell reported that France wants to return and that the Padres would love to bring him back. They need to find out what that costs while there’s still room to act on the answer. France is 32 and coming off a season that gives his agent plenty to work with.

That conversation matters to the pitching search, too. Preller has to decide how much to spend on a starter he trusts and how many innings he can get from cheaper arms. He should make those decisions with a first baseman already accounted for in the budget. If bidding on France climbs beyond what the Padres think his next few seasons are worth, use that money to pursue another everyday first baseman who can get on base and hit for extra bases. The job is to replace the production.

Add us as a preferred source on Google