1 Padres trade, 1 free agent, and 1 internal option to replace Josh Hader as closer

2 of 3

The San Diego Padres shocked the baseball world when they pulled off a stunning trade at the trade deadline that netted them Josh Hader from the Milwaukee Brewers. The Padres acquired one of the best (if not the best) closers in baseball to try and help them win the World Series.

Hader had his struggles to begin his Padres tenure, but he'd turn it on in the postseason and have an unbelievable year in 2023. The southpaw had a sparkling 1.23 ERA in 61 appearances and 56.1 innings pitched. He'd convert 33 saves in 38 opportunities. The team might've been a huge disappointment this past season, but Hader certainly did his job.

With the Padres attempting to lower their payroll for next season and the 29-year-old hitting free agency, it's safe to say his time in San Diego has come to an end. Hader seemed to hint at this partnership being over with his end-of-season Instagram post.

Now, as the Padres attempt to compete in 2024, they'll look to do so without their dominant closer. Replacing him is virtually impossible, but there are three ways they can go about finding their new closer.

1) Padres trade target to replace Josh Hader: David Bednar

David Bednar was selected by the Padres in the 35th round of the 2016 MLB Draft and had low odds of even making it to the majors. He did so with the Padres in 2019, but in his 17 appearances with the club from 2019-2020, he had a 6.75 ERA in 17.1 innings of work.

In the 2020 offseason, Bednar was one of five players the Padres traded in a three-team deal involving the Pirates and Mets that sent Joey Lucchesi to New York, Bednar to Pittsburgh, and Joe Musgrove to San Diego. The Padres obviously have done exceptionally well in that deal as Musgrove is one of the best pitchers in the National League, but Bednar has developed into a star in his own right with the Pirates.

The right-hander made his second straight All-Star team this past season and posted a 2.00 ERA in 66 appearances and 67.1 innings pitched. He led the league with 39 saves and had just three blown saves all year. He wasn't quite Hader, but he blew fewer saves in more tries even with more runs allowed.

He's excellent with three more years of team control, but the Pirates did make him available at the deadline. It'd be a steep price to pay to acquire Bednar, but it could be worth it with the gaping hole left by Hader's departure needing to be filled. Bednar is the best reliever by far who could realistically be available.

2) Padres free agent target to replace Josh Hader: Jordan Hicks

After Josh Hader, the reliever market really isn't anything to write home about. Guys like Craig Kimbrel, David Robertson, and Aroldis Chapman are available but they're all a bit older now and not as intriguing as they once were. The dream free agency target is Jordan Hicks.

Nobody throws harder, as Hicks ranked in the 100th percentile in fastball velocity averaging 100.1 mph with his sinker. A pitch that fast with movement is not fun to face. He pairs that sinker with a wicked sweeper that generated a whopping 59.5% whiff rate this past season. Again, not fun.

With the St. Louis Cardinals having a down year, they traded the free agent to be at the deadline to the Toronto Blue Jays and Hicks pitched really well for Toronto down the stretch as they tried to get into the postseason. He didn't close, but he posted a 2.63 ERA in 24 appearances serving as the Jays primary set-up man to Jordan Romano.

He's never been a full-time closer, but certainly has the stuff for it. Health has been an issue for the right-hander in the past, but he was able to make 65 appearances this season in his time with St. Louis and Toronto. If he can stay healthy he's dynamic, and when he's on, he's tough to square up. He'd thrive in the closer role in San Diego if he can stay healthy.

3) Padres internal candidate to replace Josh Hader: Scott Barlow

The Padres were fourth in the National League in reliever ERA and ninth in all of baseball in that category. Josh Hader was obviously a big reason why, but this bullpen was still very solid overall from an ERA standpoint.

The Padres have a deep bullpen and a couple of guys I believe can realistically take over for Hader and be fine. They won't be better, but shouldn't cost San Diego many games either. Robert Suarez having a healthy offseason should be huge for him as he looks to get back to his 2022 form. A dominant Suarez would be a good fit for the closer role. My pick would be Scott Barlow for the simply fact that he's done it before.

When the Friars acquired Barlow at the deadline in a deal with the Royals he was having a miserable year. He had a 5.35 ERA in 38 appearances with Kansas City before the trade but looked a lot more like the underrated reliever he had been with the Royals before this season.

Barlow was the Royals primary closer in 2021 and 2022 and had sub-2.50 ERAs in both seasons. He didn't save many games, but that had more to do with the Royals not being a good team. He had a 3.07 ERA in 25 appearances and 29.1 innings pitched with San Diego after the trade.

One thing Barlow really had to improve on was his walks as he walked 5.1 batters per nine with the Royals this season. He was able to get that down to a much more manageable 3.7 BB/9. He's at 3.6 BB/9 in his career. Barlow pitched well as his 3.15 FIP would confirm, and he's earned some trust heading into this offseason.

manual

Home / Padres Rumors

1 San Diego Padres trade, 1 free agent, and 1 internal option to replace Josh Hader as closer

1) Padres trade target to replace Josh Hader: David Bednar

2) Padres free agent target to replace Josh Hader: Jordan Hicks

3) Padres internal candidate to replace Josh Hader: Scott Barlow

Schedule