Padres’ trade deadline response to Dodgers’ Tarik Skubal blockbuster raises one huge question

Any hopes of the San Diego Padres miraculously chasing down the Los Angeles Dodgers atop the NL West died the moment that Tarik Skubal joined the two-time reigning champs. Their lead was already near insurmountable territory, and by acquiring the best pitcher in baseball, they've effectively sealed themselves off from the rest of the division.

Of course, the end goal isn't a division title. The Dodgers have accomplished that feat 12 times in the past 13 years, and it would have been foolish to expect the Friars (or anyone else) to seriously threatent that reign of terror.

As such, the Padres didn't just roll over at the sight of Skubal in the Dodgers' dugout. A.J. Preller didn't have the ammunition to match the magnitude of that deal, but he did trade a couple of top prospects in order to secure the services of Robbie Ray and Casey Mize for the rest of the year.

Now, the question is: Did the Friars close the talent gap, or did the Dodgers only widen it?

Dodgers raised ceiling at trade deadline, though Padres smartly responded by raising their floor

It's actually pretty easy to compare the trade deadline performance by both teams. Save for some additional depth picked up at the 11th hour -- catchers Ben Rortvedt and Hunter Feduccia in L.A., reliever Hunter Stratton in San Diego -- the highlights on both sides were a pair of starting pitchers.

Skubal is, obviously, the grand prize here. The two-time reigning AL Cy Young is as dominant a force on the mound as the game has today, and he'll cover for the myriad injuries plaguing the other stars on the Dodgers' staff.

The X-factor in this equation is Kris Bubic, a 2025 All-Star who has barely played this year due to elbow and shoulder issues. If he returns before the end of the season and resembles his best self, the Dodgers might be able to field two entire starting rotations.

Their acquisitions reek of gluttony, considering they already have Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Justin Wrobleski, and Roki Sasaki, not to mention injured pitchers Tyler Glasnow, Blake Snell, and Shohei Ohtani. On the other hand, the Padres acted in desperation, trying to save their season while giving Michael King some semblance of support.

Neither Ray nor Mize is on the same plane as Skubal (very few are), but both are much more sure things than Bubic is at this point in his career. Could you call that a wash in terms of the talent added?

Even if you think the Dodgers got the better collection of players, how much did they really move their own needle? They were already the better team; adding Skubal next to Yamamoto and Ohtani is a terrifying thought, but he'll bump out another very talented starter in Snell or Glasnow during the playoffs. The Padres, meanwhile, at least gave themselves a fighting chance, as they can now counter with a rotation of King, Mize, Ray, and one of Nick Pivetta or Joe Musgrove (if either are healthy).

As impossible as it seems, the NL West leaders spent the trade deadline trying to lift their already astronomical ceiling. The Friars were smart not to play their game, instead opting to raise what is now a much more stable floor.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow