Padres stun with Nick Castellanos decision in outfielder’s return to Philly

Nick Castellanos is a fun character. Let’s just start there. He’s almost always good for something. A strange quote or perfectly timed one-liner. A pregame or postgame answer that sounds like it wandered in from a completely different genre. That has always been part of the appeal. He has never really been boring. But personality can only carry a roster spot so far.

At some point, the bat has to show up. And the fun has to come with production. The Padres had to stop pretending this was still a useful experiment that had clearly run out of oxygen. And so they moved on.

The Padres designated Castellanos for assignment while they were in Philadelphia, of all places, turning what could have been a quirky reunion into something much colder. He never even got the chance to step into the batter’s box at Citizens Bank Park and take a few hacks against his former team. No ovation. No boos. Just gone.

Kind of harsh. And at the same, it all makes sense. Both things can be true, which is kind of the Castellanos arc. The timing was brutal, almost comical. But the decision itself was not an injustice. Castellanos hit .191/.221/.339 with four home runs, 20 RBI and a 57 OPS+ during his brief time with San Diego. He was worth -0.9 WAR in a sample that was not even large enough for a player to casually wave away.

The Padres could not keep waiting on the name-brand version of Nick Castellanos

This is where the mistake usually happens with veterans like Castellanos. Teams remember the damage. And they aren't wrong to be interested in that version. But they were wrong if they thought they could wait forever for him to come back.

San Diego’s offense has had too many nights where the names look better on paper than they do in the box score. This is a small admission that the Padres cannot afford to keep handing plate appearances to players who are only helping in theory.

The Padres are making it known that they are past the point of nostalgia. They need real contributors. Which brings us to Samad Taylor.

He had a strong spring and made enough noise to be part of the roster conversation before he was left behind. In Triple-A El Paso, he’s kept swinging his way back into the picture, slashing .319/.406/.500 with seven home runs and 25 RBI. And he’s getting the shot because the guy ahead of him couldn’t get it done. 

There is no need to overcomplicate it. The only awkward part about this is the setting. The Padres moved on from Castellanos in the city where his old team plays, during the very trip that could have given him a spotlight moment. Maybe not unfair, but it’s a little cold.

Still, if San Diego is trying to fix their offense, it has to be more ruthless about the difference between a recognizable name and a useful player. Castellanos was the former. Taylor now gets a chance to prove he can be the latter.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow