Padres keeping Mason Miller at the trade deadline set up an unimaginable NLDS twist

Two months ago, the Padres had to make a decision. Mason Miller was one of the biggest names floating around the trade market, San Diego’s season was wobbling and contenders were ready to make a move for the one of the most dominant relievers in baseball.

The Padres opted to keep him. And they absolutely should have. A.J. Preller isn’t the kind of guy to spend years shoving chips into the middle of the table just to fold when the cards get too uncomfortable. San Diego had already surrendered a prospect package headlined by Leo De Vries to acquire Miller from the Athletics in 2025. Trading him one year later would have amounted to ripping the emergency brake on another season.

The Padres made it to the postseason only for it to deliver a plot twist no front office could model. Miller landed on the postseason paternity list hours before a do-or-die NLDS Game 3 against the Milwaukee Brewers. His wife, Jordan, had gone into labor. Suddenly, the closer the Padres refused to trade was unavailable for the biggest game of their season.

Hey, family comes first. There’s no debate worth manufacturing there. Miller was exactly where he needed to be. The Padres still had eight innings to cover without him.

Michael King saved more than Game 3 for the Padres

Keeping Miller was supposed to shorten postseason games. Instead, his absence forced Craig Stammen to improvise while the Padres stared directly at elimination. Bradgley Rodriguez escaped the seventh inning with the use of a devastating changeup holding on to a one-run lead. Then Michael King, only two days removed from throwing five innings as the Game 2 starter, handled the final six outs of a 4-3 victory.

King’s save kept the Padres’ season alive and spared the organization from a particularly vicious round of second-guessing. San Diego paid heavily for Miller, refused to flip him when his trade value remained enormous and built its postseason identity around a dominant bullpen. One sudden absence nearly knocked the whole structure sideways.

Now consider the opponent. Milwaukee reportedly checked in on Miller before the deadline. Imagine him wearing a Brewers uniform in this series. Or the Padres trying to scratch out late runs against the closer it once controlled. What about Miller landing on the paternity list for Milwaukee and leaving the Padres to attack a depleted Brewers bullpen?

One deadline decision could have rearranged this entire situation. Instead, Miller stayed in San Diego, blew the save in Game 2 and then missed Game 3 for a far more important life event. What a whirlwind of events that could have wrecked a baseball series for either team.

The Padres cannot ask Michael King to rescue them again

How many more emergency innings can San Diego squeeze from a pitching staff already working without its closer?

Miller can return after spending the required time on the paternity list, but the Padres haven’t provided a firm timetable entering Game 4. Until he is activated, Wandy Peralta holds his roster spot. Adrián Morejón, Jason Adam and Rodriguez become even more important, while King’s workload makes another multi-inning rescue unlikely.

Walker Buehler is the Game 4 starter and he needs to provide as much length as possible. The offense needs to build a lead instead of handing the bullpen another one-run tightrope. Craig Stammen really has his work cut out for him as he tries to manage another game with the Padres’ season on the line.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow