The Padres added right-handers Tucker Musgrove and Ian Koenig to their 40-man roster on Nov. 17, protecting both pitchers from Rule 5 draft eligibility. Musgrove is this big name to watch out of the two. He struck out 42.8 percent of the hitters he faced in 2026. But he also walked 16 percent of them. The Padres have every reason to protect him after a breakout season. 2027 should tell us more about him.
San Diego drafted Musgrove in the seventh round in 2023 out of the University of Mobile, where he played both ways. He became a full-time pitcher in pro ball, underwent elbow surgery in his draft year and didn’t throw his first professional pitch until 2025. A year later, he was blowing an upper-90s fastball past hitters at the top of the zone across High-A and Double-A.
His numbers come with a little whiplash. Over 34 1/3 innings, he struck out more than two of every five hitters and walked nearly one of every six. With 35 players on the 40-man after the moves, the Padres had room to keep working with a reliever who can miss bats like this.
Tucker Musgrove’s fastball gives the Padres a reason to bet on his command
How often can Musgrove get ahead so hitters have to respect the lively fastball? If his command isn’t working, it’ll only make sense for the hitter to wait it out while looking for a mistake. Give away enough of those counts and even a fastball this good can spend more time doing very little work.
Koenig’s addition makes the difference easy to see. The former undrafted free agent made 29 starts, threw 148 1/3 innings and walked just 6 percent of hitters while working his way to Triple-A. It would make sense to stash a guy like Koenig in Triple-A for when the Padres need somebody to come up and take a turn in the rotation. With Musgrove, we’re still finding out what kind of innings he might eventually handle.
Next season we’ll have to keep an eye on how often Musgrove can stay in the zone. If he starts winning more counts, the Padres can find out how his stuff holds up against better hitters.
