Manny Machado's problem with Padres summed up with this concerning development

Jayhaykid shared a pretty ugly snapshot of Manny Machado’s season. And it honestly explains a lot. Machado against non-fastballs has gone from a strength to a full-on problem. In 2022, he hit .327 with a .649 slugging percentage, .429 wOBA and 43 percent hard-hit rate against them. That was the All Star version of Machado. 

Since then, the trend has mostly continued the wrong way. In 2025, there was at least some competence there with a .255 average, .445 slugging percentage, .315 wOBA and 42 percent hard-hit rate.

But we have not seen that guy in 2026.

This year, Machado is hitting .140 with a .269 slugging percentage, .220 wOBA and 28 percent hard-hit rate against non-fastballs. That split is pretty conducive to explaining why the whole Padres offense feels so easy to game-plan against right now.

Manny Machado’s alarming split explains too much about the Padres offense

Is Machado selling out for the fastball? Possibly. It’s not a ridiculous theory. 8 of his 11 home runs have come against the fastball, which tells us he can still turn on heat when he gets it in the right spot. 

But that explanation only helps so much because Machado is hitting just .200 against fastballs, too.

If he were crushing fastballs and merely struggling against spin, we could call it proof of concept. Still not ideal, but understandable. A veteran slugger cheating to get to velocity and trying to survive everything else? Cool. Nice way to stay productive while struggling.

But this doesn’t look like a clean trade-off. It looks like Machado is caught off balance. He’s not doing enough damage against fastballs to justify getting carved up by anything that’s not straight. And if pitchers can beat him with spin and well-located velocity, then what exactly are they supposed to fear?

Pitchers are not going to keep challenging Machado just because of the name on the back of the jersey. If he cannot punish the breaking stuff, the scouting report gets pretty simple. They will make him prove he can stay back. 

Until he does, teams are going to keep feeding him the uncomfortable stuff.

The Padres are already fighting through a miserable offensive stretch. This lineup wasn’t built around Gavin Sheets. Though he’s a fantastic surprise, but that should be a luxury, not a crutch.

Machado has been too good for too long to write off this early in the season. He and, quite frankly, Fernando Tatis Jr. have earned more patience than a random struggling hitter.

But the Padres cannot pretend this is just bad luck or normal. A .140 average and .269 slugging percentage against non-fastballs is nothing to sneeze at.

For San Diego, that’s more than a Manny problem. It is a lineup problem.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow