Diamondbacks’ Pavin Smith comeback plays right into Padres’ hands

Arizona is breathing down San Diego’s neck right now, and its latest addition is Pavin Smith. From the Padres’ side of the Wild Card race, that’s something we can live with. Entering play on Sept. 13, the Padres were 80-68. The Diamondbacks sat a game and a half behind them at 79-70. Their season series is tied 5-5, with three games at Petco Park waiting at the end of September.

One swing could flip this whole thing. That makes Smith’s return worthy of more than just a quick glance.

Smith has faced San Diego 139 times across 42 games. He has slashed .183/.259/.214 with zero home runs, six RBI and 39 strikeouts.

Pavin Smith has never solved the Padres.

The Padres have taken away his power completely and struck him out in more than 28 percent of his plate appearances. He has grounded into as many double plays against the Friars as he has driven in runs. That’s six each. Forty-two games give us a real pattern to work with. Smith has spent six seasons trying to make a dent against the Padres. All he has to show for it is four extra-base hits, all of them doubles.

Arizona knows how ugly his 2026 season became. The Diamondbacks DFA’d Smith on July 10 after he slashed .141/.236/.192 with one home run in 78 at-bats. The timing loops right back through San Diego. Arizona informed Smith of the decision immediately after a 3-1 win over the Padres. Now the Diamondbacks are bringing him back with a potential season-deciding series at Petco Park sitting two weeks away.

Smith hit .293 with seven home runs, a .418 on-base percentage and a .908 OPS in 147 at-bats at Triple-A Reno. It’s no surprise the D-backs reopened the door after that kind of showing. They also have plenty of work to do. His major-league numbers aren’t exactly a clean slate.

We’re not trying to say Smith is an automatic out, that would be the exact thing to come back and haunt the Friars late in September. The Padres still have to do their job. The advantage they have is familiarity. They don’t need a fresh scouting plan or anything. If the Diamondbacks choose to hand Smith meaningful time in the box down the stretch, the Padres already have six seasons of evidence showing they can win that confrontation.

This comeback plays directly into their hands. Arizona is turning to a familiar hitter at the exact moment when familiarity matters most.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow