Building the perfect A.J. Preller trade package for Padres to land Tarik Skubal

Great news. Ethan Salas survives this fake trade machine. Bad news? Almost every left-handed arm and a pulse might need to start packing their bags. Any trade conversation involving Tarik Skubal will be uncomfortable. We can talk about what it would take all day long, but the answer will not make you feel great. 

Even with the elbow procedure clouding the short-term picture, he’s still one of the few pitchers in baseball who can change an entire postseason conversation by himself. He recently threw bullpen sessions as part of his recovery from loose-body elbow surgery, with reports noting there’s still no firm return timeline despite encouraging progress.  

According to Bob Nightengale, if Skubal is traded at the deadline, it comes down to the Dodgers, Yankees, Blue Jays, and Padres. 

The Dodgers definitely have the prospect shine to play ball. So if A.J. Preller wants to make Detroit actually stay on the phone, the conversation probably starts with the kind of prospect pain Padres fans would immediately hate.

The Padres can keep Ethan Salas, but not their pitching upside

Yep, that means their two top lefties, Kruz Schoolcraft and Kash Mayfield, would probably have to be in the offer just to keep the Tigers from hanging up. Then comes Ryan Wideman as the surging position-player sweetener. And even then, Detroit might still ask where the rest of it is.

It's probably not enough. Skubal dealing with an injury only helps. But still, this is what it takes to shop for a two-time Cy-Young winner.

On the plus side, the Padres somehow land Skubal while keeping Ethan Salas, their most recognizable prospect and still the long-term catching hope of the organization. So, at least that part is defensible.

But keeping Salas means the Padres cannot pretend the rest of the offer gets lighter. Schoolcraft would be the headliner. He has a huge frame, standing 6-foot-8 with a lively fastball that can reach the upper 90s. The Tigers would love getting him into their pitching lab to see if they can develop him into a front-of-the-rotation option.

Detroit would absolutely want him, while San Diego would really hate moving him.

The Padres have spent years watching young pitching leave the organization and turn into someone else’s luxury. Trading Schoolcraft would, again, feel like giving away one of the few internal arms who could actually help change the long-term pitching picture.

Mayfield wouldn’t be a throw-in either. He’s leading the High-A circuit in ERA and WHIP, and has been one of the cleanest early-season development wins in the system.  

He makes sense because he offers the exact thing a team moving Skubal would need to sell itself and its fans: controllable left-handed pitching upside. For the Padres, moving another lefty arm like Mayfield would be painful because he’s starting to look like a pitcher they should also want to keep.

Preller’s entire reputation is built on refusing to be sentimental. He sees prospects as currency until they force their way into the big-league picture. Sometimes that mindset has given the Padres star power. But it also leaves fans watching former Padres prospects blossom elsewhere and wondering why the organization always seems to be buying back the same thing it just traded away.

Wideman would be the third piece that rounds the package into something more complete. He is not the headliner, but he plays an important role. He’s listed with 70-grade speed, center-field traits, and enough athleticism to make him more than just a throw-in.  

Now, would Detroit say yes? That’s where this gets tricky. Skubal’s free agency clock matters, so does his health, and Detroit’s own competitive timeline. His trade market became a real topic after he and the Tigers had a wide arbitration gap.  

There is contractual tension. The injury uncertainty. And enough ace-level upside to make every contender at least check the temperature.

For the Padres, it’s not a matter of if Skubal would fit. Of course he would on any contender. It’s more about whether the Padres can afford to solve today’s rotation problem by cutting into tomorrow’s.

With Preller, we already know the answer usually depends on how loud the opportunity is. But if you’re going to play ball on renting Skubal for the rest of the season. Winning the World Series is the only outcome. Anything else and they’d have a lot of explaining to do. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow