Skip to main content

2026 Silver Slugger Predictions: Fernando Tatis Jr. has two shots, but one better case

Right field got him on the ballot. Second base gave him an encore.
ByTremayne Person
Oct 7, 2026; San Diego, California, USA;  San Diego Padres right fielder Fernando Tatis Jr. (23) reacts after hitting a solo home run during the third inning against the Milwaukee Brewers in game four of the NLDS for the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Petco Park.  Mandatory Credit: Denis Poroy-Imagn Images
Oct 7, 2026; San Diego, California, USA; San Diego Padres right fielder Fernando Tatis Jr. (23) reacts after hitting a solo home run during the third inning against the Milwaukee Brewers in game four of the NLDS for the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Petco Park. Mandatory Credit: Denis Poroy-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Fernando Tatis Jr. has already won two Silver Sluggers as a shortstop. Now he has a chance to win one after splitting time between right field and second base, a sentence that would’ve sounded ridiculous back when we were debating whether the Padres should ever move him off short in the first place. He’s San Diego’s only finalist this year, and he’s on the ballot twice.

The season gives us plenty to work with. Tatis slashed .289/.358/.470 with an .828 OPS, 25 homers and 38 stolen bases. The question is how far that combination gets him in two fields with very different competition

Tatis has a tougher path through the NL outfield

There are three outfield awards and seven finalists. Clearly, we give Pete Crow-Armstrong the first spot after he tied for the major league lead with 45 home runs. James Wood gets the second. He still hit 30 homers with an .891 OPS despite missing time with an oblique injury. If we’re handing out an award for what a hitter did with his opportunities, that’s a hard season to pass over.

The last spot is where we’d take Seiya Suzuki. His .841 OPS and 26 homers give him a narrow edge over Tatis on the strength of his work at the plate. It’s still a close call. Jordan Walker has an argument of his own after breaking out with 29 homers and 102 RBIs, and Padres fans know how quickly Corbin Carroll can turn a routine trip through the Arizona lineup into a problem. With that many credible choices, Suzuki still has the edge at the plate to decide the last spot.

Utility is where Tatis has his best argument

Tatis at utility makes more sense, and Jake Bauers absolutely makes it uncomfortable. Bauers hit 26 homers and put up an .874 OPS while playing first base and both corner outfield spots for Milwaukee. Cincinnati rookie Sal Stewart brings the biggest home run total of the group with 32, plus work at both infield corners. If the voters put the most weight on hitting rate, we could see how Bauers would have the strongest argument. If they want the biggest power season, Stewart, the NL Rookie of the Year has a real case

Here’s where we’d give Tatis the edge. He played 120 games in right and appeared in 53 at second, giving San Diego a substantial stretch of offense from a middle-infield spot as well as his usual work in the outfield. Pair that with 181 hits and those 38 steals and take the range of ways he helped create runs. The position split explains why his candidacy belongs here. The hit total and baserunning should be what gives him an advantage.

CJ Abrams and the NL West give Padres fans more races to watch

We’d take CJ Abrams at shortstop. The former Padre and Elly De La Cruz both went 30–30, and Miami’s Otto Lopez led the NL in hits. Abrams is our pick because his combination of home run power and speed gives Washington two ways to make a pitcher pay in the same at-bat and the same inning. To be fair, Elly can as well. We’ve watched enough of the Juan Soto trade tree to know every Abrams milestone can start the old debate again. This one is worth watching for what he’s become in Washington.

Around the division, Arizona’s Gabriel Moreno has the edge over Colorado’s Hunter Goodman at catcher and Philadelphia’s Kyle Schwarber over the Dodgers’ Shohei Ohtani at DH. Goodman’s 41 homers are outrageous for a catcher, but Moreno was clearly more skillful with the bat posting a .311 average and 143 OPS.

For San Diego, utility is the result we’re most curious to hear. We already knew a healthy Tatis could hit enough to get into the outfield conversation. His second nomination captures something specific about 2026. The Padres could move him to second and still write the same bat into the lineup.

Add us as a preferred source on Google