San Diego Padres: Who Is The Real Manny Machado?

1 of 3

Manny Machado #13 of the San Diego Padres. (Photo by Denis Poroy/Getty Images) /

During the Spring of 2019 the San Diego Padres shocked the baseball world with the signing of free agent Manny Machado to a 10 year, $300 million free agent contract.

After a decade of mostly hopeless floundering in the bottom of the NL West, the San Diego Padres made a play to make themselves relevant in MLB.

All of baseball was surprised by the move. Owners Ron Fowler and Peter Seidler had vowed for the past several years that their goal was to make the Padres relevant and bring championship baseball to San Diego.

Although the fan base remained unconvinced, the owners never wavered from their commitment to changing the tide of the organization. Everyone in professional baseball shared the fans’ pessimism regarding the Padres ability to change course.

Until General Manager AJ Preller embarked on the 2016 international signing bonanza.

After several years of drafting high and often, the Padres splurged with an $80 million signing spree that captured several highly ranked international teenage prospects and required a penalty from MLB of almost equal the amount spent.

Then the signing of Eric Hosmer before the 2018 season made the pundits doubt the sanity of Preller and the ownership. Although none of the Padres draft picks or international prospects were ready to play at the major league level, the Padres signed an expensive free agent.

So when the signing of Machado was announced, the baseball brain trust opined that the Padres were jumping the gun. No way would they be able to take advantage of either Hosmer’s or Machado’s best years.

Enter the 2020 season.

The Friars have one of the top two farm systems in baseball and that is after graduating Fernando Tatis Jr, Chris Paddack, and Luis Urias from the minor league ranks.

They have a superstar in the making with Tatis Jr as well as aces in the making with Paddack, Dinelson Lamet and minor league prospects Mackenzie Gore and Luis Patino.

With a few upgrades around the diamond, the 2020 season should show a significant improvement over last year.

Manny Machado #13 of the San Diego Padres. (Photo by Sean M. Haffey/Getty Images) /

What’s next for Manny

Manny Machado did not have a great 2019 and he has readily admitted that. But he remains one of the best third baseman in baseball with many productive years ahead of him.

If the Padres coax consistent production from Hosmer, the two other outfielders not named Tommy Pham, whoever is manning second base, and even mediocre production from the catching position they could easily win over 85 games in 2020.

It is not overstating matters to say that much of the success of 2020 rests on the production and leadership from Tatis Jr and Machado.

Tatis Jr is a superstar waiting to happen and the only requirement is that he stays healthy.

Machado, on the other hand, must prove to Padres fans and the rest of baseball that he is not defined by the shortcomings of his previous mistakes in judgement or the failures of the 2019 season.

Who is the real Manny Machado?

After attending the recent Friar FanFest I began thinking about the inconsistencies that we have all seen in Machado.

It was impressive to see his enthusiasm and willingness in engaging fans during the course of the day. As well as the openness and joy he exhibited in his interview and cheerleading with the Friar Faithful. This was a different guy than we have previously experienced.

All Padres fans who follow baseball saw the guy who angered Milwaukee Brewer fans and players with the apparent dirty plays during the Dodgers/ Brewers playoffs in 2018.

We all heard about the players voting Machado as the “dirtiest player is baseball.”

After signing his contract last February, Machado said all the right things but his words seemed automatic and cliche ridden. His play, splendid at times, was inconsistent and tanked the last two months of the season.

What can Padres fans expect from a gifted but sometimes mercurial superstar?

In his interview at FanFest, Machado cited the distracting 2019 offseason that interrupted his normal workouts and preparation.

The need to settle in San Diego before the season began as well as getting to know a new organization and new teammates all contributed to his not being able to perform up to his standards.

He stated that he upped his preparation this offseason, felt better than he ever has and believes in this teams ability to bring a championship to San Diego.

He sounded sincere with genuine emotion that seemed lacking in many of his previous interviews.

Is this the Manny Machado that will lead San Diego to the promised land?

Manny Machado #13 of the San Diego Padre. (Photo by Denis Poroy/Getty Images) /

What comes next?

Much depends on this man and his ability to perform and to lead. Machado does not appear to be the rah-rah type of leader.

He shows little emotion on the field, other than the custom hand shakes and celebrations. You don’t see him rallying the troupes in the dugout or hear stories of him calling meetings after games in the clubhouse.

But that does not mean he isn’t a leader. His style seems to be more leading by example with quiet support and mentoring.

He could be of tremendous help to Tatis Jr as his career progresses. Machado knows the shortstop position. He agreed to come to the Padres and play third base despite his professed preference for shortstop. He did that for the money, of course. But he also has to recognize Tatis Jr has phenomenal skill at the position and can only make Machado look better on the left side of the infield.

My thinking has to include the reality that Machado is still a relatively young man himself. Although he has been in the big leagues since the age of 19 he just completed his age 26 season.

The best years of his career should be ahead of him, physically as well as maturity wise.

I am willing, and I think Padres fans are willing, to give Machado the benefit of the doubt regarding his lapses of judgement in the past.

Going forward, he must behave in a more mature and professional manner and I believe that the ownership of the Padres would not have signed him if they didn’t believe that would be the case.

Managing Partner Ron Fowler does not suffer fools easily and he is well known for his lack of patience with under performing players and/or poor performance. I don’t think he would have signed off on Machado’s contract unless he believed that the character of the player was adequate to support the contract.

That being said, many baseball fans will never forget Machado’s past indiscretions and that was exhibited this past weekend during FanFest when a Twitter war erupted between Padres fans and Machado haters.

The interchange highlighted that the Friar Faithful now have a player that causes a significant divide in baseball and we can expect many boos on the road when Machado comes to bat.

It remains to be seen if any further controversial plays occur during Machado’s time with the Padres. We can only hope that he will develop into a consistent and outstanding example for our young players as this decade of commitment to excellence evolves.

Machado himself has frequently stated his desire to nurture and support the young players around him as he was supported in Baltimore when he came up to the big leagues.

That goal would be greatly enhanced if he is able to harness his competitive drive on the field, develop a mature leadership role and be an example to his teammates that encourages sportsmanship.

I’m not sure if Manny Machado cares what people other than his teammates think of him. But if he wants the fans of San Diego to embrace him for the 10 years of his contract with the Padres, he would be wise to adopt the persona of the owner.

Determined to win, honest and straightforward in his assessments and a reputation for excellent work ethic and fair play.

Next. Rotation Excellence. dark

If Manny Machado can strive for those qualities as well as playing baseball as he is capable, San Diego Padres fans have a treat in store over the next nine years.

Home / Padres News

During the Spring of 2019 the San Diego Padres shocked the baseball world with the signing of free agent Manny Machado to a 10 year, $300 million free agent contract.

What’s next for Manny

What comes next?

Schedule