August 5, 2012; Denver, CO, USA; San Francisco Giants left fielder Melky Cabrera (53) runs to third base after hitting a triple during the eighth inning against the Colorado Rockies at Coors Field. The Giants won 8-3. Mandatory Credit: Chris Humphreys-US PRESSWIRE

A Case For Melky In San Diego


No, I have not lost my mind. I am sure many people will laugh at the headline of this post, and think that I have lost my mind. Well, read the whole article and yell at me later. I think the Padres should explore the option of signing disgraced Giants outfielder Melky Cabrera.

I am not being sarcastic — in fact, I have never been more serious in my life. Sure, Cabrera is a steroid cheat. Yes, he tried to concoct a hairbrain scheme to fool MLB into thinking he used a legitimate product. Is Cabrera a scumbag? Perhaps. But do not let that cloud your judgment.

Let’s go back in time to 1998 — that magical year when the Padres won the pennant. Two of my favorite players from that team, Ken Caminiti and Wally Joyner were steroid cheats. It does not ruin the memories I have of that season. In fact, that season gave me some of the best memories of my life. If you are a Padres fan, can you really disagree with me?

Anyway, back to the issue at hand. Before he tested positive for a banned substance, Cabrera was an MVP candidate, and many experts thought he could command as much as $80 million on the open market. Cabrera was on pace to win the batting title, and was the best player on a World Series contender.

In 2011, Cabrera had a huge season for the Kansas City Royals, as he became part of the first outfield (along with Alex Gordon and Jeff Francoeur) in MLB history to have all three regular outfielders smack 40 doubles. Cabrera is a solid Major League outfielder, with the versatility to play all three positions at Petco Park.

Is Cabrera’s success fueled purely by steroids? Maybe, but if the price is right, you better believe I am interested. If the Padres could get Cabrera on a one-year deal, in the neighborhood of $5 million or less, why not take a chance? The Padres clearly need an upgrade in right field, and Cabrera would provide an interesting option.

I have grown tired of Will Venable – I do not believe that he is anything more than a 4th outfielder. The Padres need an everyday player. That’s where the Melk-Man comes in. If you disagree with me, who do you want to see playing right field in San Diego next season?

Next Padres Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Aug 2424 Aug1:10at Arizona DiamondbacksBuy Tickets

Tags: Alex Gordon Jeff Francoeur Ken Caminiti Melky Cabrera San Diego Padres Wally Joyner Will Venable

  • Amish_willy

    Maybe if the Padres didn’t just get more xbh’s from RF than any other position this year I might buy into the “problem” most are selling. The duo in RF hit .280/.347/.455 with 37 2b’s, 14 3b’s, 15 HR’s, 28 sb/8 cs, and a very stellar 60bb/106k ratio. Keep in mind that RF’s out hit any other position on the 2011 team.

    Even assuming Cabrera could be had so cheaply (1/5m) that’s stil 2-3m less the team would have to spend on areas of real need versus going with the productive duo the team already has. I’d like to add that to the starter fund.

    With Venable still having 3 years of control left, he has a legit shot of reaching 20 fwar, currently at 10, while having a career best 2.7 fwar in 2012 if he were to be held onto. If Petco weren’t the worst ballpark for lefthanded hitters, I’d imagine many would be singing a different tune about Venable. When you know the park sucks for players like Venable, and he’s got a crazy good track-record on the road (.286/.365/.509, 146 wRC+ in ’12), is the player really the problem?

    With it sounding like the fences are coming in, moving Venable now would be a silly move as Venable would be the guy I’d peg for having the most benefit of the change.

  • FriarPuck

    Wally Joyner WAS NOT a steroid cheat. He took three (3) pills, Felt bad about it and flushed the rest down the toilet. Caminiti on the other hand, Took every banned substance known to man. Cabrera is an out and out cheater and a piece of trash who cares only about himself and nothing about the integrity of the game. He even tried to hide his steroid use by concocting a bogus website ! To lump Wally Joyner in the same conversation about him shows that you know absolutely NOTHING about baseball. You should be ashamed.

  • FriarPuck

    Besides, He took them in 1999 and NOT the 1998 season, So please check your facts before you go tarnishing someone’s name again.